Back to Top

Electronic Training Collars: Myths and Facts

Electronic Training Collars: Myths and Facts

Electronic training collars are loved by some people and hated by others. There are not many people who would have neutral opinion and stand somewhere 'in between'. There is plenty of one thing around electronic dog-collars – myths. Everybody, who knows at least a little about the subject, has many opinions on the issue. But only a small part of these is based on personal experience or facts. Therefore, in this text, we present 6 selected myths about electronic training collars.

Myth # 1: "Electronic Collars Are Dangerous"

Myth number 1 among dog owners is the worry that electronic dog collars are dangerous. Believe us, these concerns are misplaced. They stem from mere ignorance. The collar is powered only by a 3-9 Volt battery. The pulse that the dog can feel is far weaker than the pulse intensity that powers, for example, electric fences for cattle. The electronic dog collar impulse is painless, though a little unpleasant, tingling. Collars can be dangerous if they are not used by the owner according to the instructions.

Myth # 2: "Using a Collar will Change the Personality of the Dog"

Many critics of electronic collars say their use changes the personality of the dog. But that's not quite true. It always depends on the particular owner, how he treats his dog. An electronic collar is a tool that an owner can misuse and you can clearly see it when it is misused. Equally, you can change the nature of a dog if you beat it mercilessly. The second argument about the electronic collar changing the nature of the dog is that it is completely unnatural for the dog. But we should not work with such an argument at all. For a dog, the whole world of humans is unnatural, and yet he lives with us happily.

Myth # 3: "Using an Electronic Collar is Cruel"

This assumption is based on the idea that the electronic collar is hurting. Its use is unpleasant, but it certainly doesn’t hurt the dog as much as slapping by hand or belt. It is important to note that if we punish the dog at the wrong time, any punishment is cruel. Electronic collar, on the other hand, can prevent abuse. Imagine a situation where a dog does not obey the owner's order. This will happen to any dog sooner or later. The dog runs away and returns after some time. What will you do? Will you punish him when he comes back to you? In such a case, the dog will think it is being punished for coming back, not for disobeying. The electronic collar eliminates this problem. Using a radio that controls the collar, communication with the dog is instant. This makes it faster and easier to train the dog.

Myth # 4: "Electronic collars are painful for dogs"

This myth follows purely from ignorance of electronic collars. Modern electronic collars can be set to multiple pulse intensity settings. This means you can find the ideal level of stimulation for your dog. Before buying an electronic collar it is necessary to choose the right one. For small breeds a different type of collar is suitable than for big breeds. For small dogs such as dachshunds, the d-control 500 mini is suitable. For large dogs such as the Golden Retriever, the d-control 1000 is more suitable.

Myth # 5: "Only lazy masters buy electronic collars"

Well, it is one way to look at it. But in this case you can see the positive side of it. Acquisition of electronic collar is really for lazy owners who do not want their dog training to take months. By using an electronic collar, training will take much less time, it will be more efficient and easier. If training with an electronic collar is easier and quicker for both sides, for both the master and the dog, why not use it.

Myth 6: "Electronic collars are the last resort"

Some breeders delay the use of electronic collars as a last resort. Electronic collars can be used for puppies from 4 months of age. They are the ideal choice to teach the dog the basic commands. Electronic collars can be used regularly for small breeds too. Actually, when used properly, they can help build a great relationship between the owner and dog.

As you can see, there are plenty of myths about using electronic training collars. But these are really myths that are not based on reality. Over time, awareness of the use of such devices is improving. Proponents of electronic collars are increasing, whereas the number of opponents is decreasing.

Do you like this article? Share it please :)


Add comment

Samuel Uwak

02. 11. 2022 01:24

This a very good-written article, it will be helpful to every dog owner who utilizes it, including me. Keep doing what you are doing – can’t wait to read more posts. Also, you can check for a similar post.

Add comments to article, your email will not be published. Required information is marked with star.

I agree with processing personal data.

Follow us here

You hereby authorize VNT electronics sro, with its registered office at Dvorska 605, 563 01 Lanskroun, ID: 64793826, registered in the public register kept by the Regional Court in Hradec Kralove, Section C, Insert 9839 (hereinafter referred to as the "Administrator"), 101/2000 Coll., on the Protection of Personal Data (hereinafter referred to as the "Personal Data Protection Act"), processed the following personal data:
name and surname
any other information you write on the forms on this website or emails sent to the addresses listed on this site
The above-mentioned personal data must be processed for the purpose of drawing up an offer or contract, processing an order or sending a price list. This data will be processed by the Administrator for 1 year.

You hereby give consent to VNT electronics s.r.o., with its registered office at Dvorská 605, 563 01 Lanškroun, Identification No. (IČ): 64793826,, tel.: +420 461 310 762, entered in the Companies Register administered by the Regional Court in Hradec Králové, Section C, Entry No. 9839 (hereinafter the “Data Controller”) with processing the following personal data pursuant to Act No.101/2000, Coll., on Personal Data Protection (hereinafter the “Personal Data Protection Act”):

• Name and surname;
• E-mail; and
• All other data that you will write into the forms on this website or into e-mails sent to the addresses stated on this website.

The above-mentioned personal data must be processed for the following purposes:

• To prepare a bid or agreement, to process an order or send price lists. The data will be processed by the Data Controller for a period of one year.
• To provide a licence for the mobile application Dogtrace GPS. Said personal data concerning such application will be maintained by the Data Controller for a period of ten years after the consent was given.

You give your express consent with the above-mentioned processing. The consent may be withdrawn at any time for example by sending an e-mail or letter to the above-mentioned Data Controller’s contact data. Personal data are processed by the Data Controller, but personal data may also be processed for the Data Controller by the following processors:

• Technical controller; or
• Other providers of processing software, services and applications.

Please note that pursuant to the Personal Data Protection Act you are entitled to withdraw your consent at any time, to request information from us what personal data of yours we process, to request explanation from us concerning personal data processing, to request access to such data and to have such data updated or corrected, to request deletion of such personal data and, in case of any doubt concerning fulfilment of the obligations connected with personal data processing, to contact us or the Personal Data Protection Office.